Substituting a variable in an equation

11 views (last 30 days)
Hi,
I have a set of equations in which certain variable and values are to be substituted. But when I use the subs function, it doesn't seem to work.
syms r Y L0 L1 L2 p1 p2 x y
eqn1 = L0+L1*cos(x)+p2*cos(x+y) == r*sin(x+y);
eqn2 = L1*sin(x)+p2*sin(x+y) == Y-r*cos(x+y);
Now, x and y are given by another set of equations
x = acos((r^2-p1^2)/(r^2+p1^2));
y = acos((r^2-p2^2)/(r^2+p2^2));
I also have other set of equations for my dependent variables.
Y = r;
p1 = L0;
p2 = L1 - L0;
I need to substitute these values back into my equations and so I use subs function and it works as expected.
eqn3 = subs(eqn1);
eqn4 = subs(eqn2);
But the problem is, I need to simplify my main equations with x+y = pi/2. This is just one case and the value will change for other cases, so I can't simplify my main equations directly. I use subs function once again for this substitution process.
eqn1=subs(eqn1,x+y,pi/2);
eqn2=subs(eqn2,x+y,pi/2);
Since, the subs function replaces x and y with their corresponding equations, it is pointless to use it here, so I am using the last set of subs function before my x and y substitution and my final code looks like as below.
syms r Y L0 L1 L2 p1 p2 x y
eqn1 = L0+L1*cos(x)+p2*cos(x+y) == r*sin(x+y);
eqn2 = L1*sin(x)+p2*sin(x+y) == Y-r*cos(x+y);
x = acos((r^2-p1^2)/(r^2+p1^2));
y = acos((r^2-p2^2)/(r^2+p2^2));
Y = r;
p1 = L0;
p2 = L1 - L0;
eqn1=subs(eqn1,x+y,pi/2);
eqn2=subs(eqn2,x+y,pi/2);
eqn3 = subs(eqn1);
eqn4 = subs(eqn2);
But still, the x+y simplification doesn't seem to work and the entire equation is substituted with the values of x and y. How do I fix this?
Thanks,
Abinav

Accepted Answer

Walter Roberson
Walter Roberson on 8 Jul 2020
eqn1 = subs(eqn1, str2sym('x+y'), pi/2);
eqn2 = subs(eqn2, str2sym('x+y'), pi/2);
The reason for this is that at the point you have assigned x and y as variables, so x+y at that point is not the same as the x+y that was defined in eqn1 and eqn2.
  2 Comments
Walter Roberson
Walter Roberson on 8 Jul 2020
The code I posted is after the variable declaration, replacing you current
eqn1=subs(eqn1,x+y,pi/2);
eqn2=subs(eqn2,x+y,pi/2);
lines.
Another way of writing it would be
eqn1=subs(eqn1,sym('x')+sym('y'),pi/2);
eqn2=subs(eqn2,sym('x')+sym('y'),pi/2);
Remember that when you created
eqn1 = L0+L1*cos(x)+p2*cos(x+y) == r*sin(x+y);
that that captured the values of x and y as they were at that time, just like if you had numeric x and y
x = 3; y = 11;
eqn1 = L0+L1*cos(x)+p2*cos(x+y) == r*sin(x+y);
then you would not expect that changing the numeric x and y values would have any effect on eqn1.
The values of syms x y that were captured are references into the symbolic engine to symbolic variable x and y . When you then assign new values to x and y, the x and y at the MATLAB level no longer refer to the same location in the symbolic engine, but eqn1's references into the symbolic engine do not get updated. Not until you eqn1 = subs(eqn1) -- but you do not try to do that until after you try to subs(eqn1,x+y,pi/2) using the x and y that are no longer just the symbolic variable x and y and are instead long expressions. Those long expressions are not part of eqn1 which still has plain symbolic-x plus symbolic-y . Long-complicated x + long-complicated y has some meaning, but it does not happen to match any expression present when eqn1 was constructed.

Sign in to comment.

More Answers (0)

Products


Release

R2020a

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by