Replacing actxcontrol with actxserver
Mostra commenti meno recenti
Hi, I have a MATLAB script that communicates with multiple motor controllers. I used to use actxcontrol for this on R2022a, but due to this command no longer being supported by MATLAB as of R2025a, I am trying to switch over to using actxserver. The problem is that I get the error message 'Error: Catastrophic failure' whenever I try to send commands.
This is an example of the code using actxcontrol
ma = actxcontrol('MGMOTOR.MGMotorCtrl.1');
ma.StartCtrl;
where I get the warning
'Warning: ACTXCONTROL will be removed in a future release. For more information see UI Alternatives for MATLAB Apps on mathworks.com. '
This is an example of the code using actxserver
mb = actxserver('MGMOTOR.MGMotorCtrl.1');
mb.StartCtrl;
where I get the error
'Error using COM.MGMOTOR_MGMotorCtrl_1/StartCtrl
Error: Catastrophic failure'
I know actxserver isn't a 1 to 1 replacement for actxcontrol so I wanted to check if I'm missing a step in setting up the variable mb in order to be able to send commands.
Thank you very much!
1 Commento
Walter Roberson
circa 3 ore fa
Google AI says,
MGMOTOR.MGMotorCtrl.1 cannot be controlled directly using actxserver in MATLAB. Attempting to instantiate it via MATLAB's actxserver function and calling StartCtrl triggers a Catastrophic failure (E_UNEXPECTED) because it is an ActiveX GUI control (.ocx) rather than a headless COM Automation server. [1, 2]
Why actxserver Fails
- UI Container Requirement. Thorlabs APT ActiveX controls (MGMOTOR.MGMotorCtrl.1) require a graphical window container (such as a MATLAB figure window) to initialize their internal message loop and UI threads before hardware commands can execute. [1, 2]
- Removal of actxcontrol. Because actxcontrol has been deprecated and removed in newer MATLAB releases (R2025a+), legacy scripts relying on APT ActiveX controls cannot simply swap actxcontrol for actxserver. [1]
Recommended Migration Paths
To control Thorlabs motion hardware in modern MATLAB versions without ActiveX errors, transition to one of Thorlabs' supported .NET or C APIs:
- Thorlabs Kinesis .NET API (Standard Replacement)
- Mechanism. Load the Kinesis .NET assemblies directly into MATLAB using NET.addAssembly instead of COM/ActiveX.
- Advantage. Runs completely headless (no figure window required), supports 64-bit MATLAB natively, and works across all modern MATLAB releases.
- Resources. Official MATLAB examples and class wrappers are available in the Thorlabs Motion Control Examples repository on GitHub (Thorlabs/Motion_Control_Examples) and the MATLAB Central File Exchange. [1, 2, 3]
- Thorlabs XA Software Platform (Long-Term Support)
- Mechanism. Thorlabs' newer cross-platform motion control suite (XA), which replaces Kinesis and legacy APT.
- Advantage. Provides thread-safe, language-agnostic C/C++ and .NET APIs (usable via MATLAB's loadlibrary or NET.addAssembly) with long-term support. [1, 2]
- Legacy Workaround (Older MATLAB Versions Only)
- If you are running a MATLAB version where actxcontrol still exists (R2024b or earlier), you must host the control inside an invisible or visible figure container: [1, 2]
f = figure('Visible', 'off');
h = actxcontrol('MGMOTOR.MGMotorCtrl.1', [0 0 300 200], f);
h.StartCtrl;
set(h, 'HWSerialNum', 12345678); % Replace with device serial number
h.Identify;
Risposte (0)
Categorie
Scopri di più su Use COM Objects in MATLAB in Centro assistenza e File Exchange
Community Treasure Hunt
Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!
Start Hunting!