Surface area from a z-matrix

37 visualizzazioni (ultimi 30 giorni)
bobby
bobby il 15 Apr 2012
I have x, y axis values and corresponding z values. This allows me to plot the shape using surf function. Example:-
How to calculate surface area of this irregular shape?
Please i'm a novice learning this stuff, i have come along quite well since last week or two. Thank you for all your help. The other answers provided before for irregular shapes have me confused, since i don't know how to triangulate.
Additionally i also want to calculate surface area above a certain height. So i'll cut all the values below a certain height and then possibly calculate surface area above a cut-off height.
Edit:
Thanks to inputs by the community and basically whole programme written by Richard. Here's the code.
function sa(Z, cutoff)
%Credit: Richard Brown, MATLAB central forum (http://www.mathworks.com/matlabcentral/answers/)
dx=0.092; % x-axis calibration
dy=0.095; % y-axis calibration
[m, n] = size(Z);
areas = 0.5*sqrt((dx*dy)^2 + (dx*(Z(1:m-1,2:n) - Z(1:m-1,1:n-1))).^2 + ...
(dy*(Z(2:m,1:n-1) - Z(1:m-1,1:n-1))).^2) + ...
0.5*sqrt((dx*dy)^2 + (dx*(Z(1:m-1,2:n) - Z(2:m,2:n))).^2 + ...
(dy*(Z(2:m,1:n-1) - Z(2:m,2:n))).^2);
zMean = 0.25 * (Z(1:m-1,1:n-1) + Z(1:m-1,2:n) + Z(2:m,1:n-1) + Z(2:m,2:n));
areas(zMean <= cutoff) = 0;
surfaceArea = sum(areas(:));
sprintf('Total surface area is %2.4f\n', surfaceArea)
return
end
  1 Commento
Richard Brown
Richard Brown il 15 Lug 2013
Modificato: Richard Brown il 15 Lug 2013
I've just had it pointed out to me that there is a small mistake in this code. Assuming that x corresponds to columns, and y to rows, then the first two lines (but not the second two lines) of the areas calculation has dx and dy backwards. I've fixed it in my original answer below.

Accedi per commentare.

Risposta accettata

Richard Brown
Richard Brown il 16 Apr 2012
Modificato: Richard Brown il 15 Lug 2013
OK, well how about splitting each quadrilateral into two triangles, and just summing up the areas? I'm sorry there's no way I can make this look pleasant, but ...
[m, n] = size(Z);
areas = 0.5*sqrt((dx*dy)^2 + (dy*(Z(1:m-1,2:n) - Z(1:m-1,1:n-1))).^2 + ...
(dx*(Z(2:m,1:n-1 - Z(1:m-1,1:n-1)))).^2) + ...
0.5*sqrt((dx*dy)^2 + (dx*(Z(1:m-1,2:n) - Z(2:m,2:n))).^2 + ...
(dy*(Z(2:m,1:n-1) - Z(2:m,2:n))).^2)
surfaceArea = sum(areas(:))
edit: Jul 15, 2013 There was a mistake, and dx and dy were backwards in the first two lines of the code. The code has been corrected now.
  3 Commenti
bobby
bobby il 16 Apr 2012
Now how to find the surface area above a cut-off height. The present code connects the empty valleys and assumes it to a flat surface. I want to exclude them. Any intelligent ideas?
Richard Brown
Richard Brown il 16 Apr 2012
For each of the areas in the 'areas' array, you could work out the mean Z value
zMean = 0.25 * (Z(1:m-1,1:n-1) + Z(1:m-1,2:n) + Z(2:m,1:n-1) + Z(2:m,2:n))
and then
areas(zMean > cutoff) = 0;
surfaceArea = sum(areas(:));
It's a bit sloppy - you should probably do this for the individual triangles, but it will certainly give you a reasonable approximation

Accedi per commentare.

Più risposte (3)

Walter Roberson
Walter Roberson il 15 Apr 2012
I do not know if you will be able to calculate the surface area of the regular shape interspersed with the irregular tops. When I look at the image with the irregular tops, it looks to me as if the tops are fairly irregular, possibly even fractal. I don't know if a meaningful surface area could be calculated: the surface area of a fractal is infinite.
For the first figure, I can think of a crude way to find the area, but I think there are simpler ways. I would need to think further about good ways to find the area. But to cross-check: are your x and y regularly spaced, or irregularly ?
  7 Commenti
Sean de Wolski
Sean de Wolski il 16 Apr 2012
I wasn't commenting on Richard's script at all, but rather the fractal nature of surface area (and length) of irregular shapes. I apologize if that came across the wrong way.
http://www.google.com/#hl=en&gs_nf=1&cp=19&gs_id=1k&xhr=t&q=how+long+is+the+coast+of+britain&fp=46b06bf633a62cc4
bobby
bobby il 16 Apr 2012
Ah, the good old mandelbrot. Yes, I understand your point now. That is why i edited my post as i did understood that it will be nearly impossible. But the surface area of the surface that i'm after, given in the post, i'm sure a solution exists. Thanks to you i came across a very neat paper by Mandelbrot.

Accedi per commentare.


Richard Brown
Richard Brown il 16 Apr 2012
If your data is smooth enough (assuming that's what you're after), then there is a really quick way to work out approximately the surface area, using the normals that Matlab computes when plotting the surface. To make it simple I'll assume you have a uniform grid with spacings dx and dy.
dA = dx * dy;
h = surf( ... )
N = get(h, 'VertexNormals');
N_z = squeeze(N(:, :, 3));
% Normalise it
N_z = N_z ./ sqrt(sum(N.^2, 3));
Area = dA * sum(1./N_z(:));
  3 Commenti
bobby
bobby il 16 Apr 2012
Thank you Richard for your interest and guidance. That is a very neat way of getting surface area. Yes, the grids are uniformly spaced. I am after a quite accurate solution here, since between different surfaces there can be a very small difference and i need to know that. This script is way off right now, way more than 2sigma. So i was looking at some TIN algorithms, i will create triangulated meshes and find individual triangle area. But even after spending weekend on this, i am nearly nowhere.
Richard Brown
Richard Brown il 16 Apr 2012
Hence my comment about smoothing - if you apply that straight to the mesh you've got there, all bets are off! Anyway, see my next answer, it might be more in line with what you're after.

Accedi per commentare.


bobby
bobby il 16 Apr 2012
function surfacearea(Z, cutoff)
dx=0.092;
dy=0.095;
[nrow, ncol] = size(Z);
for m=1:nrow
for n=1:ncol
zMean = mean(Z(1:m-1,1:n-1) + Z(1:m-1,2:n) + Z(2:m,1:n-1) + Z(2:m,2:n));
if(zMean >= cutoff)
areas = 0.5*sqrt((dx*dy)^2 + (dx*(Z(1:m-1,2:n) - Z(1:m-1,1:n-1))).^2 + ...
(dy*(Z(2:m,1:n-1) - Z(1:m-1,1:n-1))).^2) + ...
0.5*sqrt((dx*dy)^2 + (dx*(Z(1:m-1,2:n) - Z(2:m,2:n))).^2 + ...
(dy*(Z(2:m,1:n-1) - Z(2:m,2:n))).^2);
end
end
end
surfaceArea = sum(areas(:));
return
end
This is how the final code looks like with a cut-off limit included. Any inputs into speeding up this code? I have 1024*1280 matrix.
  3 Commenti
bobby
bobby il 17 Apr 2012
Oh yes. This does not require loops. Let me run it again. Thanks Richard.
bobby
bobby il 17 Apr 2012
Yes, the code runs fast, only thing is there should be < sign. Thanks a lot Richard for helping me through this ordeal. I'll definitely shop again. :)

Accedi per commentare.

Categorie

Scopri di più su Fractals in Help Center e File Exchange

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by