Avoid for loop: Looping through rows of m-by-n logical array

8 visualizzazioni (ultimi 30 giorni)
Postedit: Read the comments below the accepted answer!
Is it possible to view the rows of a logical array independently without using a for-loop?
x = randi(5, 1, 10) % create 1x10 vector containing random integers between 1 & 5
y = randi(5, 1, 10)
xVals = unique(x)' % get column-vector of unique values of x
tf = x == xVals % logical array, that shows for every unique x-value, at which indices it occurs in x.
for i = 1:size(tf,1) % loop through rows of logical array
yVals(i) = {y(tf(i,:))}; % Assign all y-values that belong to one xVal-entry to one cell.
end

Risposta accettata

Matt J
Matt J il 20 Apr 2018
Modificato: Matt J il 20 Apr 2018
[~,~,idx] = unique(x);
yVals=accumarray(idx,y,[],@(x){x(:).'}).'; 
  2 Commenti
Zwithouta
Zwithouta il 20 Apr 2018
Modificato: Zwithouta il 25 Apr 2018

@ Matt J

Thanks for the answers, guys, but that's not exactly what I'm looking for. Let me ask my question better.

If you have a logical array a

a = logical([0 1 0
             0 1 1 
             0 0 1])

and a cell array b

b = [1 2 3
     4 5 6
     7 8 9]
b = mat2cell(b, [ones(1,3)], [ones(1,3)]);

Logical indexing will give the following output

b(a) 
ans =
4×1 cell array
  {[2]}
  {[5]}
  {[6]}
  {[9]}

That is, the information about which row & column the verified cells had in b is lost when you use logical indexing.

Is it possible to use logical indexing (not other methods, like accumarray) in a way, that it preserves this information? The output should then look like this

3×1 cell array
  {[2]}
  {[5,6]}
  {[9]}

After all, all information needed for this output is contained in the logical array, but is then kind of voluntarily dropped by Matlab.

Matt J
Matt J il 20 Apr 2018
Modificato: Matt J il 20 Apr 2018

After all, all information needed for this output is contained in the logical array, but is then kind of voluntarily dropped by Matlab.

Well, the logical array by itself doesn't have all the information. You need to tell MATLAB for example that each cell should contain row data and not column data. Otherwise, why couldn't {[2;5], [6;9]} be the result?

The closest thing giving what you are asking for would be the following, I think:

yVals=arrayfun(@(i) b(i,a(i,:)) , 1:size(b,1),'uni',0  ).'

This doesn't really avoid a for-loop however, except syntactically.

Accedi per commentare.

Più risposte (2)

Matt J
Matt J il 20 Apr 2018
Modificato: Matt J il 20 Apr 2018

Another way,

yVals = splitapply( @(g){g(:).'}, y, findgroups(x))

Bruno Luong
Bruno Luong il 21 Apr 2018
Modificato: Bruno Luong il 21 Apr 2018

For older MATLAB version, this FEX might be useful SplitVec

c = SplitVec(sortrows([x;y]'),1,2)

When stable ordering of y is desired

c = SplitVec(sortrows([x;y]',1),1,2)

Prodotti

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by