Spooky behavior with anonymous functions
1 visualizzazione (ultimi 30 giorni)
Mostra commenti meno recenti
Andrew Liu
il 12 Mar 2021
Commentato: Andrew Liu
il 15 Mar 2021
I noticed some useful but freaky behavior with anonymous functions and would like to understand the low-level details a bit better so I use this functionality without constant paranoia that it will blow up in my face. The behavior is easier to explain by example:
F = @(x)x+1;
for k = 1:5,F = @(x)F(x)+1;end
F(1)
% ans = 7
So it looks like MATLAB is retaining the definition of each instance of F *somewhere*. I can even save F as a mat file, and, upon reloading, F will retain this definition. Is there any way to peek into this "somewhere"? One use case is where I have a class with function handles as properties, and I want to composite those functions via overloaded arithmetic operations:
myObj1.F = @(x)x+1;
myObj2.F = @(x)x-1;
myObj3 = myObj1+myObj2; %where myObj3.F = @(x)x+1-1 or something like that
but myObj3.F will actually be something like @(x)myObj1.F(x)+myObj2.F(x)... so what happens if I clear myObj1 and/or myObj2? If someone else is examining myObj3, how could they tell what F is?
tl;dr: When nesting anonymous functions, if the variable instantiated with the anonymous function is overwritten or "cleared," the definition still seems to exist somewhere. How can a user view it?
0 Commenti
Risposta accettata
Steven Lord
il 12 Mar 2021
If you want to see what information an anonymous function "remembers" for debugging purposes only you can do so using the functions function. Do not attempt to use this to try to change the anonymous function (it won't work) or as part of how you use anonymous functions in the normal operation of your program (as per the Note on the functions documentation page.)
Più risposte (0)
Vedere anche
Categorie
Scopri di più su Function Creation in Help Center e File Exchange
Community Treasure Hunt
Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!
Start Hunting!