# Not your typical vertcat error. Weird behaviour with it.

1 visualizzazione (ultimi 30 giorni)
Mario Malic il 11 Mag 2023
Modificato: VBBV il 11 Mag 2023
Hey,
I am not sure what's going on with editor, but I am having issues in understanding why does dxdt does not work properly. The error is about vertcat.
% Error using vertcat
% Dimensions of arrays being concatenated are not consistent.
Here is the code
m1 = parameters(1);
m2 = parameters(2);
k1 = parameters(3);
k2 = parameters(4);
d1 = parameters(5);
d2 = parameters(6);
% Output equation.
y = [x(1)]; % Displacement of the smaller mass
Now we execute each row of dxdt (further below) and we see the result
x(2)
ans = 50
(-((k1+k2)*x(1))/m1) + ((k2*x(3))/m1) - (((d1+d2)*x(2))/m1) + ((d2*x(4))/m1) +u(1)
ans = -416.6667
x(4)
ans = 50
(d2*x(2)/m2) - (d2*x(4)/m2) + (k2*x(1)/m2) - (k2*x(3)/m2) + 0
ans = 0
But if I want to do it this way, it doesn't work. Issue is that I have to add extra parentheses on the second element, but there should be none!
% State equations.
dxdt = [x(2); ...
(-((k1+k2)*x(1))/m1) + ((k2*x(3))/m1) - (((d1+d2)*x(2))/m1) + ((d2*x(4))/m1) +u(1); ...
x(4); ...
(d2*x(2)/m2) - (d2*x(4)/m2) + (k2*x(1)/m2) - (k2*x(3)/m2) + 0];
Error using vertcat
Dimensions of arrays being concatenated are not consistent.
##### 0 CommentiMostra -2 commenti meno recentiNascondi -2 commenti meno recenti

Accedi per commentare.

### Risposta accettata

VBBV il 11 Mag 2023
m1 = parameters(1)
m1 = 12
m2 = parameters(2)
m2 = 13
k1 = parameters(3)
k1 = 100
k2 = parameters(4)
k2 = 100
d1 = parameters(5)
d1 = 0
d2 = parameters(6)
d2 = 0
% Output equation.
y = [x(1)] % Displacement of the smaller mass
y = 50
x(2)
ans = 50
(-((k1+k2)*x(1))/m1) + ((k2*x(3))/m1) - (((d1+d2)*x(2))/m1) + ((d2*x(4))/m1) +u(1)
ans = -416.6667
x(4)
ans = 50
x(3)
ans = 50
x(4)
ans = 50
(d2*x(2)/m2) - (d2*x(4)/m2) + (k2*x(1)/m2) - (k2*x(3)/m2) + 0
ans = 0
(-((k1+k2)*x(1))/m1) + ((k2*x(3))/m1) - (((d1+d2)*x(2))/m1) + ((d2*x(4))/m1) +u(1)
ans = -416.6667
(d2*x(2)/m2) - (d2*x(4)/m2) + (k2*x(1)/m2) - (k2*x(3)/m2) + 0
ans = 0
% State equations.
dxdt = [x(2);(-((k1+k2)*x(1))/m1) + ((k2*x(3))/m1) - (((d1+d2)*x(2))/m1) + ((d2*x(4))/m1) + u(1);
x(4); (d2*x(2)/m2) - (d2*x(4)/m2) + (k2*x(1)/m2) - (k2*x(3)/m2) + 0]
dxdt = 4×1
50.0000 -416.6667 50.0000 0
##### 5 CommentiMostra 3 commenti meno recentiNascondi 3 commenti meno recenti
Mario Malic il 11 Mag 2023
Modificato: Mario Malic il 11 Mag 2023
Oh my... I thought I was going crazy. I should take some time off. 😂
Thank you.
VBBV il 11 Mag 2023
Modificato: VBBV il 11 Mag 2023
As you said, it works when parenthesis is added, it's again because of operator precedence. Parenthesis () operator has the higher precedence in equation than others, so when you add a () it then delineates everything within the outermost () as ONE expression or element in matrix and evaluates it, otherwise it's treated as 2 different elements

Accedi per commentare.

### Categorie

Scopri di più su MATLAB in Help Center e File Exchange

R2023a

### Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by