MATLAB Answers


Symbolic boolean function error at evaluation

Asked by timo
on 20 Mar 2017
Latest activity Commented on by John Smith on 23 Apr 2018
clear all
syms x b a
x(a,b) =xor(a,b)
y(a,b) = and(or(a,b),(not(and(a,b))))
I get an error at y(0,0). Can someone help ?
Error using symengine
The operand is invalid.
Error in sym/subs>mupadsubs (line 150)
G = mupadmex('symobj::fullsubs',F.s,X2,Y2);
Error in sym/subs (line 135)
G = mupadsubs(F,X,Y);
Error in symfun/feval>evalScalarFun (line 42)
y = subs(formula(Ffun), Fvars, inds);
Error in symfun/feval (line 28)
varargout{1} = evalScalarFun(F, Fvars, varargin);
Error in symfun/subsref (line 175)
B = feval(A,inds{:});


Sign in to comment.

2 Answers

Answer by Renee Bach on 27 Mar 2017

I was able to isolate the error at y(0,0) to the "or(a,b)" function in "y(a,b)". You are getting this error because you need to use logical operators (and, or, ~, |, &, ...) with symbolic expressions and variables. Always make sure that you use logical expressions, such as:
y(a,b) = or(a~=0, b~=0);
"x(0,0) does not cause an error because "xor" in the Symbolic engine works not only on logical values, but also accepts numbers. This does not match other the other functions, so you should try to always use logical expressions.

  1 Comment

This gives something unexpected:

>> subfn(x1,x2) = or(x1~=0, x2~=0); subfn(1,0)
ans =
0 ~= 0 | 1 ~= 0

And while it still converges to the correct value:

>> subfn(x1,x2) = or(x1~=0, x2~=0); simplify(subfn(1,0))
ans =

I suppose it's not the best way of doing this.

Sign in to comment.

Answer by John Smith on 23 Apr 2018

Symbolic Toolbox has some own weird boolean constants: TRUE and FALSE. I couldn't yet find the less tricky way of obtaining them than this:
TRUE = sym(1) | 1;
FALSE = sym(0) & 0;
Then if you do:
>> subfn(x1,x2) = or(x1, x2); subfn(1,0)
Error using symengine (line 59)
The operand is invalid.
>> subfn(x1,x2) = or(x1, x2); subfn(FALSE,TRUE)
ans =


Sign in to comment.