calculate tangent of 1e100

3 visualizzazioni (ultimi 30 giorni)
Ben Petschel
Ben Petschel il 27 Set 2012
How do you calculate trig functions with very large arguments?
For example, in "Surely you're joking, Mr Feynman", Richard tells how he claimed to be able to solve within 60 seconds and within 10 percent any problem that can be stated in 10 seconds, but is stumped when asked to calculate tan(10^100).
MATLAB gives tan(1e100) = -0.4116 whereas google returns -0.6895. Which one is more accurate?
The MATLAB algorithm seems to not be based on simple remainders mod 2*pi, since tan(mod(1e100,2*pi)) returns 0.
  1 Commento
Seth DeLand
Seth DeLand il 27 Set 2012
Using Symbolic Toolbox I got:
>> vpa('tan(1e100)',100)
ans =
0.4012319619908143541857543436532949583238702611292440683194415381168718098221191211467267309749320831

Accedi per commentare.

Risposta accettata

Tom
Tom il 27 Set 2012
Modificato: Tom il 27 Set 2012
Given that
eps(1e100) = 1.9427e+84
it won't be that accurate.
For what it's worth, sin(1e100)/cos(1e100) gives the same answer.
(DuckDuckGo says that Wolfram Alpha says it's 0.4012319619908143541857543436532949583238702611292440)

Più risposte (0)

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by