Why This Vectorization of my Code Does Not Work?

Consider the following two codes:
n = 4;
% Code 1:
c1 = zeros(floor(n/2)+1,n+1); c1(1,1) = 1; c1(1,2:n+1) = 2.^(0:n-1);
for k = 2:n
for l = 1:floor(k/2), c1(l+1,k+1) = -((k - 2*l + 2)/(4*l*(k - l)))*(k - 2*l + 1)*c1(l,k+1); end
end
c1
% Code 2:
c2 = zeros(floor(n/2)+1,n+1); c2(1,1) = 1; c2(1,2:n+1) = 2.^(0:n-1);
for k = 2:n
lend = floor(k/2); c2(2:lend+1,k+1) = -((k-2*(1:lend)+2)./(4*(1:lend).*(k-(1:lend)))).*(k-2*(1:lend)+ 1).*c2(1:lend,k+1)';
end
c2
The first code gives
while the second gives

Risposte (1)

Might be some problem with indexing. Try this:
clc; clear all ;
n = 4;
% Code 1:
c1 = zeros(floor(n/2)+1,n+1);
c1(1,1) = 1;
c1(1,2:n+1) = 2.^(0:n-1);
for k = 2:n
for l = 1:floor(k/2)
c1(l+1,k+1) = -((k - 2*l + 2)/(4*l*(k - l)))*(k - 2*l + 1)*c1(l,k+1);
end
end
c1
% Code 2:
c2 = zeros(floor(n/2)+1,n+1);
c2(1,1) = 1;
c2(1,2:n+1) = 2.^(0:n-1);
for k = 2:n
lend = floor(k/2);
% c2(2:lend+1,k+1) = -((k-2*(1:lend)+2)./(4*(1:lend).*(k-(1:lend)))).*(k-2*(1:lend)+ 1).*c2(1:lend,k+1)';
l = 1:lend ;
c2(2:lend+1,k+1) = -((k - 2*l + 2)./(4*l.*(k - l))).*(k - 2*l + 1).*c1(l,k+1)';
end
c2

1 Commento

Kareem Elgindy
Kareem Elgindy il 14 Lug 2020
Modificato: Kareem Elgindy il 14 Lug 2020
Works like a charm :-). But what is wrong in indexing in the previous code?... I still don't get it!! One more thing. In your 2nd code you used c1. In fact, c2 is calculated using previous values of c2 only not c1.

Accedi per commentare.

Prodotti

Release

R2019b

Richiesto:

il 14 Lug 2020

Modificato:

il 14 Lug 2020

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by