Why do I get correlation result NaN?
6 visualizzazioni (ultimi 30 giorni)
Mostra commenti meno recenti
Bharath kumar boyanapalli
il 13 Ago 2021
Commentato: Walter Roberson
il 17 Ago 2021
I have two matrices A is of 1*1058 and B is 1*1058, both matrices have some NaN values included in them. Is there any way to get correlation between these two matrices.
0 Commenti
Risposta accettata
Ive J
il 15 Ago 2021
Unless you have a good reason to impute your missing data, you can remove missing values from both vectors.
nanidx = isnan(A) | isnan(B);
corr(A(~nanidx), B(~nanidx))
9 Commenti
Ive J
il 16 Ago 2021
Yes that's the whole idea!
% step 0-create two sample vectors with 5 missing values
sz = 100;
A = rand(sz, 1);
B = rand(sz, 1);
A(randperm(sz, 5)) = nan;
B(randperm(sz, 5)) = nan;
% step 1-find missing values in both vectors
nanidx = isnan(A) | isnan(B);
% step 2- remove the indices in step 1
cleanA = A(~nanidx);
cleanB = B(~nanidx);
% step 3- calculate the correlation coeff.
R = corr(cleanA, cleanB); % NOTE: by default Pearson correlation is used in corr function
% step 4- report it
fprintf('Pearson R is %.2f\n', R)
Walter Roberson
il 16 Ago 2021
That's what Ive J's code does: removes all locations for which X is nan or Y is nan.
Più risposte (1)
Chunru
il 13 Ago 2021
Use "fillmissing" to fill up the nans before computing the correlation. doc fillmissing for more details.
7 Commenti
Chunru
il 17 Ago 2021
Anyway, if you have data with so many NANs, you need to doubt your data first before doubting the processing techniques. There is not fool proof technique for filling missing data. It all depends on what data you have and what you want.
Walter Roberson
il 17 Ago 2021
Mathematically, if you have vectors A and B, then
cAB = corr(A,B);
P = randperm(numel(A));
pA = A(P);
pB = B(P);
cpAB = corr(pA, pB);
then cAB needs to equal cpAB to within round-off. The order of the elements relative to each other in their same vectors do not matter: only the correspondance between the two vectors matter.
If, though, you were to fillmissing(A) and compare that to fillmissing(pA) then you would get different results, because fillmissing works based upon nearby values, under the assumption there is some kind of smooth continuity. This is not really compatible with the mathematics of correlation which does not care about order within the sequence.
If you have some prediction function for your vectors, then Yes, it might make sense to apply that prediction function. It might even make sense to apply something like narx to predict in some cases. But that would have to be done based upon knowledge of what the vectors represent. fillmissing() has no knowledge of what they represent.
Vedere anche
Categorie
Scopri di più su Descriptive Statistics in Help Center e File Exchange
Community Treasure Hunt
Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!
Start Hunting!