- there are no symbolic 4d plotting routines
- with the work-arounds needed to represent 4d, you will not be able to get the general shape of the curve.

1 view (last 30 days)

I would like to plot the following function:

where g is the only known constant = 9.8. How should I plot this function z(r) without specifying exact values for H,C,and r ? I just need the general shape of this function (including r = 0 where there should be an asymptote)

Walter Roberson
on 26 Nov 2020

You have 3 independent variables and 1 dependent variable. You will need a 4D plot. Unfortunately:

- there are no symbolic 4d plotting routines
- with the work-arounds needed to represent 4d, you will not be able to get the general shape of the curve.

If you just want to see the shape with respect to r then I recommend that you do pick specific values of H and C, as the choice will not matter for the purposes of seeing the shape of the curve, provided that H and C are real valued. You might as well choose H=0 and C=sqrt(2*g) which would make the equation -1/r^2 which you can fplot.

However there is no asymptope at r=0, there is a singularity to infinity unless C=0

Stephan
on 26 Nov 2020

g = 9.8;

r = -10:0.1:10;

H = -10:0.1:10;

C = -10:0.1:10;

fun = @(r,H,C) H - C.^2./(2*g*r.^2);

z_r = fun(r,1,1);

z_H = fun(1,H,1);

z_C = fun(1,1,C);

subplot(3,1,1)

plot(r,z_r,'b-','LineWidth',2)

title('Varying r in the range (-10...10), H=1, C=1')

xlabel('r')

ylabel('z')

subplot(3,1,2)

plot(H,z_H,'b-','LineWidth',2)

title('Varying H in the range (-10...10), r=1, C=1')

xlabel('H')

ylabel('z')

subplot(3,1,3)

plot(C,z_C,'b-','LineWidth',2)

title('Varying C in the range (-10...10), H=1, r=1')

xlabel('C')

ylabel('z')

Stephan
on 26 Nov 2020

When C, H known:

g = 9.8;

r = -10:0.1:10;

fun = @(r,H,C) H - C.^2./(2*g*r.^2);

z_r = fun(r,0.35,1);

plot(r,z_r,'b-','LineWidth',2)

title('r in the range (-10...10), H=0.35, C=1')

xlabel('r')

ylabel('z')

or:

g = 9.8;

H = 0.35;

C = 1;

fun = @(r) H - C^2./(2*g*r.^2);

fplot(fun,[-10 10],'b-','LineWidth',2)

title('r in the range (-10...10), H=0.35, C=1')

xlabel('r')

ylabel('z')

John D'Errico
on 26 Nov 2020

Edited: John D'Errico
on 26 Nov 2020

You have the relationship

z(r) = H - C^2/(2*g*r^2)

If H and C are not known, with g fixed at 9.8, then they make this into an entire family of curves. But the family varies trivially as a function of H and C. (For that matter, the entire curve is pretty basic, but I won't go there.) And plotting the entire family would make the result into a 4 dimensional thing.

But suppose you knew H and C? I'll write z as a function of all parameters, with g fixed.

g = 9.8;

z = @(r,H,C) H - C^2./(2*g*r.^2);

That now builds the value of g into z. We could plot z, for a known pair of H and C.You suggested C == 1, H = 0.35.

fplot(@(r) z(r,0.35,1),[0,5])

h = gca;

h.YLim = [-5,.5];

yline(0.35);

I added the black line to indicate the upper asymptote. As r-->0 from the right, this curve appoaches -inf, so there is a singularity at 0.

Could you overlay additional curves on top of that, showing the behavior of the curve as H varies? Well, yes. It would get complicated though, and more difficult to visualize.

If you change H, the entire curve becomes translated vertically in y.

Changing C changes only the scaling on the Y axis.

Honestly, those parameters are pretty simple in how they change the curve, but if you tried to stuff all that into one plot, it would become unwieldy and difficult to visualize. You might try picking just a few values for H, thus...

fplot(@(r) z(r,0.35,1),[0,5],'k')

hold on

fplot(@(r) z(r,0.5,1),[0,5],'r')

fplot(@(r) z(r,0.25,1),[0,5],'r')

fplot(@(r) z(r,0.35,2),[0,5],'b')

fplot(@(r) z(r,0.35,.5),[0,5],'b')

legend('H = 0.35,C = 1','H = 0.5,C = 1','H = 0.25,C = 1','H = 0.35,C = 2','H = 0.35,C = 0.5')

h = gca;

h.YLim = [-5,1];

As you can see, this becomes complex, even for a simple set of parameter variations. Far easier to just understand how the curves vary.

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!
## 0 Comments

Sign in to comment.