Plotting a smooth curve from points
Mostra commenti meno recenti
I'm trying to plot a smooth line for 6 points in such a way that slope at each is zero. I have successfully achieved it for middle points using 'pchip' but I also want it for extreme points i.e. x=0 and x=15 which I am unable to do while using 'pchip'.
Here is my code
clear
clc
x = [0;3;6;9;12;15];
y = [0;1.9190;-3.2287;3.5133;-2.6825;1];
xi = linspace(min(x), max(x), 150); % Evenly-Spaced Interpolation Vector
yi = interp1(x, y, xi, 'pchip');
figure
plot(x, y, 'b')
hold on
plot(xi, yi, '-r')
hold off
grid
xlabel('X')
ylabel('Y')
legend('Original Data', 'Interpolation', 'Location', 'NE')
3 Commenti
Image Analyst
il 23 Gen 2021
How do you know that the slope is exactly zero at the knot/training points? And why do you need the slope to be zero there?
Osama Anwar
il 23 Gen 2021
The slopes are very close to 0. Vertical lines show the original x-values without the endpoints.
x = [0;3;6;9;12;15];
y = [0;1.9190;-3.2287;3.5133;-2.6825;1];
xi = linspace(min(x), max(x), 150);
yi = interp1(x, y, xi, 'pchip');
% compute slopes
s = gradient(yi, 150);
plot(xi,s)
yline(0)
arrayfun(@xline, x(2:end-1)
Risposta accettata
Bruno Luong
il 24 Gen 2021
Modificato: Bruno Luong
il 24 Gen 2021
Direct analytic method using piecewise cublic polynomial. The curve is first-order differentiable, but not second order differentiable (as with sublic spline or result with my first answer using BSFK)
x = [0;3;6;9;12;15];
y = [0;1.9190;-3.2287;3.5133;-2.6825;1];
[xx,is] = sort(x(:));
yy = y(is);
yy = yy(:);
dx = diff(xx);
dy = diff(yy);
y0 = yy(1:end-1);
n = numel(xx)-1;
coefs = [-2*dy./(dx.^3), 3*dy./(dx.^2), 0*dy, y0];
pp = struct('form', 'pp',...
'breaks', xx(:)',...
'coefs', coefs,...
'pieces', n, ...
'order', 4,...
'dim', 1);
figure
xi = linspace(min(x),max(x));
yi = ppval(pp,xi);
plot(x,y,'b-o',xi,yi,'r');
xlim([min(x),max(x)])
grid on
Propably this is how John generates his curve
x = [0 1 1.5 2 4];
y = x;
10 Commenti
Osama Anwar
il 24 Gen 2021
Bruno Luong
il 24 Gen 2021
Phi=[0,0,0,0,0;0.284629676546570,-0.830830026003772,1.30972146789057,-1.68250706566236,1.91898594722899;0.546200349457202,-1.08815592122522,0.372785597771793,1.39787738911579,-3.22870741511956;0.763521118433367,-0.594351144437141,-1.20361562377557,0.521108558113203,3.51333709166613;0.918985947228994,0.309721467890570,-0.715370323453430,-1.83083002600377,-2.68250706566236;1,1,1,1,1]
x = [-3;0;3;6;9;12;15;18];
y = [2;Phi(:,1);-2];
% ...
Osama Anwar
il 24 Gen 2021
Modificato: Osama Anwar
il 24 Gen 2021
Osama Anwar
il 24 Gen 2021
Osama Anwar
il 24 Gen 2021
Modificato: Osama Anwar
il 24 Gen 2021
Bruno Luong
il 24 Gen 2021
You meant this:
Simply reverse in the plot
Phi=[0,0,0,0,0;0.284629676546570,-0.830830026003772,1.30972146789057,-1.68250706566236,1.91898594722899;0.546200349457202,-1.08815592122522,0.372785597771793,1.39787738911579,-3.22870741511956;0.763521118433367,-0.594351144437141,-1.20361562377557,0.521108558113203,3.51333709166613;0.918985947228994,0.309721467890570,-0.715370323453430,-1.83083002600377,-2.68250706566236;1,1,1,1,1]
x = [0;3;6;9;12;15];
y = [Phi(:,1)];
[xx,is] = sort(x(:));
yy = y(is);
yy = yy(:);
dx = diff(xx);
dy = diff(yy);
y0 = yy(1:end-1);
n = numel(xx)-1;
coefs = [-2*dy./(dx.^3), 3*dy./(dx.^2), 0*dy, y0];
pp = struct('form', 'pp',...
'breaks', xx(:)',...
'coefs', coefs,...
'pieces', n, ...
'order', 4,...
'dim', 1);
figure
xi = linspace(min(x),max(x),257);
yi = ppval(pp,xi);
plot(y,x,'bo',yi,xi,'r');
grid on
xlabel('y')
ylabel('x')
Osama Anwar
il 24 Gen 2021
Osama Anwar
il 27 Gen 2021
Bruno Luong
il 27 Gen 2021
Sorry you are on your own if you use symbolic variables. Once you modify/adap the code it's yours.
I don't have this toolbox to help, even if I want to .
Osama Anwar
il 27 Gen 2021
Più risposte (2)
You could add values to the beginning and end to make the curve continuing in both directions. The example below uses hard-coded values but it wouldn't be difficult to programmatically extend the trend in the opposite y-direction on each side of X.
x = [-3;0;3;6;9;12;15;18];
% ^^ ^^ added
y = [2;0;1.9190;-3.2287;3.5133;-2.6825;1;-2];
% ^ ^^ added
xi = linspace(min(x), max(x), 150);
yi = interp1(x, y, xi, 'pchip');
% Trim the additions
rmIdx = xi<0 | xi>15;
xi(rmIdx) = [];
yi(rmIdx) = [];
x([1,end]) = [];
y([1,end]) = [];
figure
plot(x, y, 'b')
hold on
plot(xi, yi, '-r')
hold off
grid
xlabel('X')
ylabel('Y')
legend('Original Data', 'Interpolation', 'Location', 'NE')
13 Commenti
Osama Anwar
il 23 Gen 2021
Adam Danz
il 23 Gen 2021
I just update the answer to add the 5 lines under "Trim the additions".
To make the solution programmatic you just need to implement these steps.
- Determine if the slope of + or - at the end points. That's easy. At each endpoint you just need to determine if the y-value of the end point is greater or less than the y-value of the neighboring coordinate.
- Compute the median x-interval: median(diff(x))
- Compute the median y-distance from center: median(abs(y)) (since your curve is centered at y=0)
- Add a coordinate to the right of the curve by adding the median x-interval to the x-value of the endpoint and set the y values as the median y-distance with its sign opposite to the end point's slope.
- Do the same for the left end-point by subtracting the median x-interval.
Osama Anwar
il 23 Gen 2021
Adam Danz
il 23 Gen 2021
That's true. x-interval isn't important.
Osama Anwar
il 23 Gen 2021
Adam Danz
il 23 Gen 2021
Yes, that's true, too. Thanks for following up!
John D'Errico
il 23 Gen 2021
I can think of a few ways to do this. Adam's solution is a nice one though. +1
John D'Errico
il 23 Gen 2021
Modificato: John D'Errico
il 23 Gen 2021
Hmm, as I think and re-read the question, this solution works ONLY if each point is an extremeum.
Is the target to have an interpolant that has zero slope at each point, even for a sequence of points that follow a straight line? For example, consider the points:
x = [0 1 1.5 2 4];
y = x;
plot(x,y,'-o')
Or, is this next curve your goal?
Adam's solution will not produce the latter curve in general. So which is your goal?
Osama Anwar
il 24 Gen 2021
Osama Anwar
il 24 Gen 2021
Osama Anwar
il 24 Gen 2021
Modificato: Osama Anwar
il 24 Gen 2021
Adam Danz
il 24 Gen 2021
Yeah, it's not a robust hack.
I'm following the conversation. John and Bruno have great points.
Osama Anwar
il 24 Gen 2021
Bruno Luong
il 24 Gen 2021
Modificato: Bruno Luong
il 24 Gen 2021
No extra points needed (but you might add to twist the shape of the curve in the first and last interval),
Spline order >= 8th is needed using my FEX
x = [0;3;6;9;12;15];
y = [0;1.9190;-3.2287;3.5133;-2.6825;1];
interp = struct('p', 0, 'x', x, 'v', y);
slope0 = struct('p', 1, 'x', x, 'v', 0*x);
% Download BSFK function here
% https://www.mathworks.com/matlabcentral/fileexchange/25872-free-knot-spline-approximation
pp = BSFK(x,y, 9, length(x)-1, [], struct('KnotRemoval', 'none', 'pntcon', [interp slope0]));
% Check
figure
xi = linspace(min(x),max(x));
yi = ppval(pp,xi);
plot(x,y,'b',xi,yi,'r');
for xb=pp.breaks
xline(xb);
end
grid on
4 Commenti
Bruno Luong
il 24 Gen 2021
With Adam's trick
x = [0;3;6;9;12;15];
y = [0;1.9190;-3.2287;3.5133;-2.6825;1];
% Adam's trick
xx = [-3;x;18];
yy = [2;y;-2];
interp = struct('p', 0, 'x', x', 'v', y');
slope0 = struct('p', 1, 'x', x, 'v', 0*x);
% Download BSFK function here
% https://www.mathworks.com/matlabcentral/fileexchange/25872-free-knot-spline-approximation
pp = BSFK(xx,yy, 9, length(x)-1, [], struct('KnotRemoval', 'none', 'pntcon', [interp slope0]));
% Check
figure
xi = linspace(min(x),max(x));
yi = ppval(pp,xi);
plot(x,y,'b',xi,yi,'r');
for xb=pp.breaks
xline(xb);
end
xlim([min(x),max(x)])
grid on
Bruno Luong
il 24 Gen 2021
Monotonic data
x = [0;3;6;9;12;15];
y = x;
% Adam's trick
xx = [-3;x;18];
yy = xx;
interp = struct('p', 0, 'x', x', 'v', y');
slope0 = struct('p', 1, 'x', x, 'v', 0*x);
% Download BSFK function here
% https://www.mathworks.com/matlabcentral/fileexchange/25872-free-knot-spline-approximation
pp = BSFK(xx,yy, 9, length(x)-1, [], struct('KnotRemoval', 'none', 'pntcon', [interp slope0]));
% Check
figure
xi = linspace(min(x),max(x));
yi = ppval(pp,xi);
plot(x,y,'b-o',xi,yi,'r');
for xb=pp.breaks
xline(xb);
end
xlim([min(x),max(x)])
grid on
Osama Anwar
il 24 Gen 2021
Bruno Luong
il 25 Gen 2021
Modificato: Bruno Luong
il 26 Gen 2021
The shape might not meet your (un-written) expectation but it definitively meets every requiremenrs you state in the question. The interpolating solution is trully "smooth" (I believe up to the 7th derivative order is continue) with zero slope at the give abscissa.
This illustres one of the difficulty using spline fitting/interpolating: the chosen boundary conditions affects globally the shape of the interpolation.
It might be still useful for futur readers.
Categorie
Scopri di più su Surface and Mesh Plots in Centro assistenza e File Exchange
Community Treasure Hunt
Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!
Start Hunting!
Translated by 
