Is NaN ok here?
1 visualizzazione (ultimi 30 giorni)
Mostra commenti meno recenti
Vadim Potorocha
il 20 Nov 2020
Commentato: Vadim Potorocha
il 20 Nov 2020
%coin txt
5.00000000e-01 5.00000000e-01
%crime txt
1.66000000e-01 6.60000000e-02 1.40000000e-02 3.90000000e-02 1.40000000e-02 2.70000000e-02 7.20000000e-02 1.00000000e-03 9.00000000e-03 1.30000000e-02 5.50000000e-02 9.00000000e-03 2.80000000e-02 3.80000000e-02 2.60000000e-02 5.50000000e-02 9.60000000e-02 2.30000000e-02 3.50000000e-02 4.50000000e-02 5.40000000e-02 2.40000000e-02 1.00000000e-03 7.00000000e-03 2.00000000e-03 1.50000000e-02 7.00000000e-03 3.00000000e-03 0.00000000e+00 1.40000000e-02 1.80000000e-02 3.00000000e-03 5.00000000e-03 1.80000000e-02
%unfair.txt
9.99000000e-01 1.00000000e-03
%ventsel.txt
1.45000000e-01 6.40000000e-02 1.50000000e-02 3.90000000e-02 1.40000000e-02 2.60000000e-02 7.40000000e-02 8.00000000e-03 1.50000000e-02 6.40000000e-02 1.00000000e-02 2.90000000e-02 3.60000000e-02 2.60000000e-02 5.60000000e-02 9.50000000e-02 2.40000000e-02 4.10000000e-02 4.70000000e-02 5.60000000e-02 2.10000000e-02 2.00000000e-03 9.00000000e-03 4.00000000e-03 1.30000000e-02 6.00000000e-03 3.00000000e-03 1.50000000e-02 1.60000000e-02 3.00000000e-03 7.00000000e-03 1.90000000e-02
%ralph.txt
3.36184163e-02 1.43227594e-01 1.64970470e-01 1.34046838e-01 7.52792246e-02 6.54570283e-02 5.34771727e-03 9.39337045e-02 1.06252105e-01 1.77866902e-01
%ALPH_ENTROPY FUNCTION
function h = alph_entropy(P)
h = sum(-P .* log2(P));
end
%APLH_REDUNDANCY FUNCTION
function r = alph_redundancy(P)
r = sum(1 - (alph_entropy(P)./log2(P)));
end
%main.m
A = load("coin.txt",'-ascii')
B = load("crime.txt",'-ascii')
C = load("unfair.txt",'-ascii')
D = load("ventsel.txt",'-ascii')
E = load("ralph.txt",'-ascii')
Z = [alph_entropy(A) alph_redundancy(A); alph_entropy(B) alph_redundancy(B) ; alph_entropy(C) alph_redundancy(C); alph_entropy(D) alph_redundancy(D); alph_entropy(E) alph_redundancy(E)];
save results.txt Z -ascii;
MATRIX RESULT
%results.txt
1.00000000e+00 4.00000000e+00
NaN NaN
1.14077577e-02 9.90444552e+00
4.41966505e+00 5.87982853e+01
3.06961940e+00 1.90521746e+01
0 Commenti
Risposta accettata
John D'Errico
il 20 Nov 2020
Modificato: John D'Errico
il 20 Nov 2020
Sure. It does not bother me. Why does it bother you?
B = [1.66000000e-01 6.60000000e-02 1.40000000e-02 3.90000000e-02 1.40000000e-02 2.70000000e-02 7.20000000e-02 1.00000000e-03 9.00000000e-03 1.30000000e-02 5.50000000e-02 9.00000000e-03 2.80000000e-02 3.80000000e-02 2.60000000e-02 5.50000000e-02 9.60000000e-02 2.30000000e-02 3.50000000e-02 4.50000000e-02 5.40000000e-02 2.40000000e-02 1.00000000e-03 7.00000000e-03 2.00000000e-03 1.50000000e-02 7.00000000e-03 3.00000000e-03 0.00000000e+00 1.40000000e-02 1.80000000e-02 3.00000000e-03 5.00000000e-03 1.80000000e-02];
alph_entropy = @(P) sum(-P .* log2(P));
alph_entropy(B)
ans =
NaN
Why is that?
B(29)
ans =
0
In fact, B(29) was 0.00000000e+00.
Your entropy formula will generate NaN when any element is exactly zero. And since the redundancy code uses the entropy computation, it too results in NaN.
So what do you expect? Looks fine.
When you see a problem, LOOK AT YOUR DATA. THINK ABOUT WHAT YOUR CODE IS DOING.
You might decide if you can just drop any zero elements of the vector. Does that make sense?
3 Commenti
John D'Errico
il 20 Nov 2020
If it is homework, then you might look at the formulas for entropy, and decide how zero impacts the result you would expect. Would deleting zero elements be a problem? You were given this as homework, so you are the one who is supposed to think.
Più risposte (1)
KSSV
il 20 Nov 2020
You have alph_entropy output as 1. log2(1) will be zero and when it is divided i.e. when it is denominator; you will get NaN.
Vedere anche
Categorie
Scopri di più su Get Started with MATLAB in Help Center e File Exchange
Community Treasure Hunt
Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!
Start Hunting!